Hello dear
Welcome to My New Joint
**About My New Joint**Situated at 22658 Overseas Hwy in Cudjoe Key, My New Joint is a culinary haven that captivates the senses. Renowned for its mouthwatering sandwiches, such as the Mary's Blaze Burger and the sauteed local fish, this charming joint also boasts a selection of scrumptious fried root vegetables and delectable cocktails. Patrons rave about the vibrant atmosphere and friendly service, with standout items like the Loaded Tater Tots and craft cocktails ensuring a delightful experience. Whether you're indulging in their raw bar or savoring the acclaimed Voodoo Shrimp, each visit promises a memorable taste adventure that you'll eagerly look forward to.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
House Smoked Fish Dip
Cucumber Mule
Maple Smoke Manhattan
Hemingway Haze
About
My New Joint
Welcome to My New Joint, a hidden gem nestled on Cudjoe Key, Florida, at 22658 Overseas Hwy. This charming eatery is not just another stop along the way; it’s an experience filled with delightful flavors and a warm atmosphere that keeps guests returning year after year. The inviting space is designed with care, creating an ambiance that makes you feel right at home.
At My New Joint, the menu boasts a mouthwatering selection that includes their renowned Filet Mignon Sliders, perfectly complemented by caramelized onions and zesty horseradish sauce. For those in the mood for a comforting snack, you can indulge in their Loaded Tater Tots, packed with jalapeno cheese, bacon, and scallions for just $12. If your cravings lean towards classic fries, their Shoe String Fries seasoned with parmesan and fresh herbs served with a zesty ranch dip are a must-try at $8. Take it up a notch with crispy Tater Tots drizzled with ketchup and buffalo hot sauce, also available for $8. Each dish calls out to be shared, sparking joy in every bite.
For cocktail lovers, My New Joint offers a creative drink menu that is sure to impress. The Ian’s Gin Drank combines Fords Gin with the freshness of lemon and lime juice, honey basil, all for $12. If you seek a tropical escape, Nick's 420 Kush, featuring Captain Morgan and Malibu blended with pineapple juice, is calling your name! Don’t miss the Purple Trainwreck made with Tito’s Vodka and fresh pomegranate juice—a vibrant and refreshing delight worth its $12 price tag.
The rave reviews from customers echo the quality and service at My New Joint. Jennifer Hallett praises the atmosphere and the fabulous Voodoo Shrimp, while Julie Schwartz notes the great appetizers and cheerful service. With each visit, patrons report exceptional experiences, highlighted by friendly staff who treat customers like family.
As a food reviewer, I can personally attest that My New Joint encapsulates everything a dining experience should be: a dedication to quality, a welcoming vibe, and a menu filled with exciting options. Whether you are local or just visiting the Keys, this spot promises not just a meal, but a memorable culinary adventure. So, gather your friends, raise a glass, and dive into the delightful flavors of My New Joint! You won’t be disappointed.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ A hidden gem! If I could give them 10 stars I would. Try Voodoo Shrimp! Coconut mojito shown in pic. Atmosphere makes this well designed and thought out space. Chris the bartender was awesome. Entertainment was fabulous. ”
“ Great place. I prefer over Square Grouper on theain level due to typically no wait, and yet decent food although less variety than the Square. Nice appetizers, drinks, and limited main courses, but everything is quality a delicious. Never been disappointed. Great deserts, I recommend the Magic Bar. The cheese flight was generous compared to most. Always cheerful atmosphere and service. ”
“ Another rare 5 star from me. Stone crabs oysters, lolly pop wings just to start. Amazing craft draft beer selection and upscale cocktails in keys mode. ”
“ Can’t say enough about the friendliness of and efficiency of the staff. Always a great experience. Big shout out to the staff for turning my jacket into lost and found AND then when I called about it, shipping it to me! We always go to enjoy the variety of small plates. While I don’t eat oysters, my sister loves going during ‘happy hour’ and gets two dozen of the garlic Parmesan oyster every time we go and she says they are the best. Thanks My New Joint for always providing the best dining experience! ”
“ I always look forward to coming to this place when visiting the keys. Fabulous raw bar selection and a drink menu that will satisfy everyone’s needs. Can’t forget the giant pretzel with the horseradish mustard that will clear your sinuses right out!! Already counting down the days until next year when we visit ... ”
“ Great vibe! Fun place to meet friends or just a night out. They have shuffleboard to make time pass while listening to music. Their oysters are excellent, served with the most delicious mignonette, no crackers needed for these puppies! Enjoy a craft cocktail or craft one of your own from their wide selection of spirits. This is a place you'll want to keep coming back to! ”
“ Great spot if you are in Cudjoe, we met friends for cocktails and they were good pours! Large selection of craft beer, bourbon and tequila. My Old Fashioned was on point. Definitely one of the nicest and cleanest bars in all of the keys. Cold air and not your typical keys style place. If you are looking for a nice place to take your lady or your man out after a long day of fishing this is it! ”
“ Tonight, we were greeted by Ian. A long-time bartender. He hasn't seen us since last season. He remembers our name and drinks. He is fantastic and always makes us feel right at home. Nice to see him again! We started our meal with Blue Point Oysters! Fantastic! Hubby had the Wahoo and Tater Tots. It was on Catch if the day special! He said it was delicious! I had a Philly cheese quesadilla. Really good! I also had Cauliflower Au Gratin, delicious! The Wine and Alcolhol selection is subpurb! Music was pleasant , good sound! I would like to give a shot out to Lynn Bell. "The new Bar chairs are perfect! Thank You!! ”